Absolute Auction vs Reserve Auction: Which Format to Use
When to run an absolute auction vs a reserve auction — mechanics, legal disclosure, risk profile, and the psychological effect on bidders.
运营手册··约 11 分钟阅读
翻译进行中——目前显示英文版本。
约 11 分钟阅读
An absolute auction sells the lot to the highest bidder at any price with no minimum — the auctioneer is contractually committed to the hammer. A reserve auction protects the seller with a confidential minimum (the reserve), and if bidding doesn't reach it the lot is "passed" or "bought in" and remains unsold. Absolute auctions generate stronger bidder competition and are commonly used in real-estate, equipment, and forced-sale contexts; reserve auctions dominate fine art, jewelry, and high-value collectibles where downside protection matters more than maximum velocity.
Choosing between absolute and reserve format is a strategic decision that affects who turns up to bid, how aggressively they bid, what your sell-through looks like, and what legal disclosures you owe. This guide compares the two formats on mechanics, appropriate use cases, legal/regulatory framing, risk profile, and bidder psychology — with examples from real-estate, art, and equipment auctions.
The mechanics, side by side
Dimension
Absolute auction
Reserve auction
Minimum price
None — sells at any opening bid
Confidential minimum (the reserve)
Seller's right to refuse a sale
None — seller is bound to highest bid
Seller can withdraw if reserve not met
Disclosure to bidders
Must be advertised as "absolute" or "no reserve"
Bidders know there is a reserve but not the figure
Auctioneer's discretion to pass
None — must hammer to the highest bidder
Must pass if reserve not met
Typical sell-through
~99%+
65–85% depending on category
Bidder turnout
Higher — perceived as "real" sale
Lower in some categories — perceived as "set price disguised"
Opening bid
Often very low; auctioneer signals seriousness early
Typically opens above ~50% of the low estimate
Average hammer relative to fair value
Variable — can over- or under-sell
Tighter to the fair-value range, anchored by reserve
The auctioneer opens the lot with a low call — sometimes a token figure to surface the lowest serious bid in the room, sometimes a more anchoring number — and the bidding proceeds normally. There is no point at which the auctioneer is permitted to "pass" the lot or refuse to hammer. The hammer falls on whatever the highest bid is when bidding stops, and that hammer is binding on both buyer and seller.
The implicit commitment is what creates bidder turnout. Bidders know that something is going to sell here. They show up, register, do their research, and place real bids. The downside for the seller is real: a $4M property listed absolute can hammer at $1.2M if the room is thin and the underbidders don't show.
Reserve auction mechanic
The seller and the auctioneer agree on a confidential reserve before the sale. The auctioneer typically opens the bidding above 50–60% of the low estimate to start finding the bidders, takes calls and increments toward the reserve, and either:
Sells: bidding crosses the reserve. From that point the lot is officially "on the market" and any further bid wins it. The auctioneer hammers to the highest bidder.
Passes: bidding stops below the reserve. The auctioneer announces "pass" or "bought in" and the lot remains the consignor's property.
The reserve is not disclosed publicly. Bidders have to estimate where it sits. Skilled auctioneers signal proximity to the reserve through tone and the speed of taking bids, but they do not name the figure. After the sale, an unsold lot is often offered to the underbidder via private treaty over the next 30–60 days, and many bought-in lots clear this way.
When to use each
The format choice depends on the consignor's risk tolerance, the bidder pool dynamics in the category, and any commercial or legal constraint forcing the issue.
Real estate and property auctions
Real-estate auctions in the United States divide along absolute vs. reserve lines almost cleanly:
Forced/distressed sales (foreclosure, court-ordered, IRS, sheriff sale) — almost always absolute, because the seller is a court or lender that needs the property converted to cash with finality.
Voluntary owner-driven sales — usually reserve, because the owner won't accept a 40%-of-value outcome.
A 2024 industry sample of US real-estate auctions showed absolute sales achieved roughly 95–99% sell-through versus 60–75% for reserve sales — but reserve sales averaged 8–15% higher hammers when they did sell. Absolute is the velocity choice; reserve is the price-protection choice.
UK property auctions (much larger volume than the US — ~30,000 monthly searches for "property auction") are almost entirely reserve sales; the guide price is published, and the actual reserve is set within 10% of the guide. The Auctioneers Act 1845 and standard RICS conditions govern conduct.
Fine art, jewelry, watches
Reserve, almost without exception. The major international houses (Christie's, Sotheby's, Phillips, Bonhams) run virtually all of their flagship sales as reserve auctions because the asymmetry of one bad outcome on a $15M painting outweighs the bidder-turnout benefit of going absolute. The historical exceptions are charity sales and single-owner curated sales where the consignor is content to commit to the room.
Fine art has experimented with "no-reserve" sales — Phillips' "Editions" sales sometimes feature no-reserve sections, and several online-only houses run no-reserve as a default. Sell-through is excellent; average prices are lower than reserve-protected equivalents.
Equipment and industrial
Absolute is the dominant format. Ritchie Bros., the global heavy-equipment auctioneer, runs almost exclusively absolute sales — their entire competitive position depends on the credibility of "everything sells." Bidders fly in, inspect, and bid knowing the trucks are leaving with someone today.
Charity and benefit auctions
Almost always absolute (or "no reserve") because the social context demands it. A charity auction that passes a lot embarrasses the donor and the recipient. Some sophisticated charity formats run a reserve on signature lots with an undisclosed donor-funded backstop bid that ensures the lot clears at the reserve if the room doesn't get there.
Single-owner / estate sales
Mixed. White-glove single-owner curated sales (the "Property from the Collection of X" format that Christie's and Sotheby's run) typically use reserves but the entire sale is choreographed for sell-through, and reserve-passes embarrass the marketing campaign. Estate liquidation sales run absolute because the executor needs cash and the residual property cleared.
Legal and regulatory framing
The legal disclosure requirements differ materially between the two formats and across jurisdictions.
United States
Uniform Commercial Code §2-328 governs auctions. Sales are presumed to be with reserve unless explicitly advertised as "without reserve" or "absolute."
An advertised absolute auction is binding on the seller — the seller cannot withdraw the lot once the auctioneer has called for bids. State laws layer on top: Tennessee, North Carolina, Georgia, and Alabama have specific absolute-auction statutes requiring the words "absolute auction" in advertising. Failure to honor an advertised absolute auction is actionable.
A reserve auction allows the seller to withdraw the lot at any time before the hammer falls. The auctioneer can also pass the lot if the reserve isn't met.
Real estate auctions face additional state-level disclosures (auctioneer license, real-estate license overlap).
United Kingdom
The Sale of Goods Act 1979 §57 governs auctions. Absent a stated reserve, the sale is presumed to be without reserve.
The Auctioneers Act 1845 sets the regulatory framework for conduct.
Reserve auctions must disclose that there is a reserve in the conditions of sale; the figure remains confidential. The published "guide price" must be set in good faith and is required by RICS/NAVA codes to fall within a defined range of the actual reserve (typically ±10%).
Absolute auctions are uncommon outside of forced sales and charity contexts.
European Union
Member-state-level regulation but generally aligned with UK position.
5AMLD applies to high-value transactions regardless of format.
Asia-Pacific
Hong Kong follows the Sale of Goods Ordinance — broadly equivalent to the UK SGA 1979.
Australia: state-level regulation, with Victoria and NSW requiring specific disclosures for reserve sales.
Singapore: aligned with UK common-law approach.
The single most important legal point: if you advertise a sale as absolute, you must run it absolute. Pulling a lot mid-sale or refusing the highest bid is actionable and ruinous to reputation.
Risk profile
The two formats allocate risk very differently between the seller and the buyer.
Absolute auction risk
Seller bears all the downside. A thin room means a low hammer, and there is no floor.
Buyer bears almost no risk other than the normal due-diligence risk on the lot itself (condition, title, authenticity).
The auctioneer's commercial risk is reputational: if a property hammers at 30% of expected value, the consignor will not consign again and word travels.
Reserve auction risk
Seller has downside protection — the reserve.
Buyer bears the no-sale risk of wasted travel, due-diligence, and emotional commitment if the lot passes.
Auctioneer bears the no-sale risk of unrecovered marketing, photography, and catalogue costs on a bought-in lot. This is why most houses charge a small bought-in fee (5–10% of low estimate) — partial cost recovery for the unsuccessful sale.
This risk allocation is why categories with lumpy buyer turnout (fine art, jewelry, classic cars) almost always use reserve, while categories with predictable thick demand (industrial equipment, foreclosure real estate) can run absolute.
Bidder psychology
The format affects bidder behaviour in ways that are easy to overlook.
What absolute does to bidders
Higher turnout. "Absolute" or "no reserve" in marketing copy increases registrations 20–40% in most categories. Bidders read it as a quality signal that the seller is committed.
More aggressive opening bids. Knowing the lot will sell, bidders will compete from the start rather than holding back to see if the lot reaches reserve.
Bargain hunters in disproportion. Some absolute auctions over-attract bargain hunters who push opening bids extremely low. Skilled auctioneers manage this with starting calls that anchor expectations higher.
What reserve does to bidders
Information game. Bidders try to estimate the reserve from auctioneer body language, tempo, and how quickly bids are taken. Sophisticated bidders enter at the reserve to skip the warm-up.
Held-back bidding. Bidders are reluctant to commit psychologically to a lot they're not sure will actually sell, so opening bids on reserve auctions often sit at 50–60% of the low estimate.
Bought-in stigma. A bought-in lot is widely visible (sale results are published), and the next time the lot comes to auction it carries a "burned" stigma that depresses the next sale by 10–20%. This is why sophisticated consignors prefer to set conservative reserves and accept slightly lower hammers rather than risk the no-sale.
Hybrid and softer variants
Several formats sit between the pure absolute and pure reserve poles.
No-reserve catalogue with marquee reserved lots. An online house may run a 200-lot sale where 180 are no-reserve "starter" lots and 20 are reserve-protected feature lots. Common in online-only collectibles sales.
House guarantees. The house (or a third-party guarantor) commits to a minimum price to the consignor. The lot can then be marketed as "guaranteed" without disclosing the reserve, and the guarantor takes the downside risk in exchange for a share of overage.
Irrevocable bids. A pre-secured bid from a known bidder that ensures the lot crosses a reserve threshold. Disclosed to other bidders via a symbol in the catalogue (typically a triangle or filled circle).
Online-only "soft reserves" — a published reserve that is technically advisory; the auctioneer has discretion to sell below it with consignor approval. Rarely used at scale.
These hybrids let auctioneers blend reserve protection with the marketing punch of "this lot will definitely sell." They are most common in fine art and jewelry.
How-to steps
Choosing absolute vs. reserve format
Step 01
Confirm the consignor's risk tolerance
Ask explicitly: what is the worst hammer figure they would accept? If the answer is meaningfully above zero, you need a reserve. If they say 'whatever the room delivers,' absolute is on the table.
Step 02
Read the category's bidder-pool depth
Categories with predictable thick demand (heavy equipment, foreclosure real estate, charity) tolerate absolute. Categories with lumpy demand (fine art, watches, jewelry) need reserve protection.
Step 03
Check legal/regulatory constraints
Confirm advertising and disclosure requirements in your jurisdiction. In the US, several states require the literal phrase 'absolute auction' in advertising. In the UK and EU, reserves must be disclosed in conditions of sale.
Step 04
Consider a hybrid
If you want absolute marketing without absolute downside, structure a house guarantee or irrevocable bid. This costs you margin but transfers downside to a guarantor.
Step 05
Set the reserve, if reserve format
Reserve at 70–80% of low estimate is the standard for fine art and decorative arts; real estate often goes higher (85–90% of guide). Document the reserve in writing with the consignor.
Step 06
Configure the conditions of sale and marketing copy
Absolute sales must use the words 'absolute auction' or 'no reserve' in advertising in jurisdictions that require it. Reserve sales must disclose the existence of a reserve and any guide price.
Step 07
Brief the auctioneer
Auctioneer needs to know the reserve, the consignor's flexibility on it, and any irrevocable bid in place. Briefing happens at the rostrum check, not on the day.
Step 08
Run the sale and document the outcome
Whether the lot sells or passes, document the room conditions, underbidder identity, and any post-sale interest. This information shapes the next sale's format choice for similar lots.
Common questions
An absolute auction sells the lot to the highest bidder regardless of price — there is no minimum and the seller cannot withdraw. A reserve auction protects the seller with a confidential minimum price; if bidding doesn't reach the reserve, the lot is passed and remains unsold. Absolute auctions have higher sell-through and bidder turnout; reserve auctions average higher hammers when they do sell, with downside protection for the seller.
Use absolute when the consignor needs cash and finality (forced sale, estate liquidation, charity), when the bidder pool in your category is predictable and thick (heavy equipment, distressed real estate), or when sell-through is more important than maximum hammer. Avoid absolute on objects with lumpy demand or where one bad outcome is unrecoverable — fine art, jewelry, classic cars.
No. Once an absolute auction has been advertised and the auctioneer has called for bids, the seller is contractually bound to the highest bid. Withdrawing or refusing to hammer is actionable. Several US states (Tennessee, North Carolina, Georgia, Alabama) have specific statutes enforcing this.
Yes — the existence of a reserve is disclosed in the conditions of sale. The actual reserve figure is confidential. Bidders try to estimate it from auctioneer tempo and from any published guide price; sophisticated bidders sometimes open at the reserve to skip the warm-up.
Real estate has predictable thick demand and forced-sale circumstances (foreclosure, court order) that justify absolute format and require finality. Fine art has lumpy demand — a $15M painting may have only three serious bidders worldwide on any given day, and absolute format exposes the seller to a thin-room outcome that can destroy the lot's perceived value for a generation. Reserve format protects against that.
The auctioneer announces 'pass' or 'bought in' and the lot remains the consignor's property. The house typically holds the lot for 30–60 days post-sale to negotiate an after-sale offer with the underbidder; many bought-in lots clear this way. If no after-sale buyer emerges, the lot is returned to the consignor or re-offered in a future sale, often at a lower estimate.